How to Choose a Dog Collar That Lasts
Tips & Training
A collar is the one piece of gear a dog wears through every walk, nap, cuddle and car ride, so it has to feel comfortable from the very first buckle. Learning how to choose a dog collar comes down to four things: the right type for the job, a fit you check with your hands rather than a size label, a material that suits how your dog spends the day, and a little care to keep it safe for years.
This guide walks through each of those, with advice from three collar makers: Rebecca Martin of Remy & Co, a boutique specializing in designer and bespoke collars; Katie Day of WOOF New York, a luxury leather brand; and Ruth O'Leary, the Sydney leather crafter behind Ruthless Leather. More makers in the same spirit are gathered in the dog collars, leads and harnesses directory.
What to Look for in a Dog Collar
A good dog collar fits snugly enough that it cannot slip over your dog's head, with room for two fingers to slide underneath. It carries an ID tag, uses rust-proof hardware such as solid brass or stainless steel, and is made from a material that suits your dog's lifestyle: washable nylon or waterproof biothane for active, water-loving dogs, and soft leather for everyday city walks.
Start With Your Dog's Everyday Routine
Before thinking about color, think about the day your dog actually lives. Rebecca Martin encourages owners to start there: "If you are getting a new puppy, go for a fabric collar that is light and adjustable, that way as your precious pooch grows, you can adjust the collar. Make sure the collar you choose is machine washable as pups have a knack of getting into mischief!" This new puppy checklist covers the rest of the first-week kit, collar included.
A few simple questions narrow the search quickly. Does your dog swim? Roll in mud? Need the collar for walks, for training, or simply to carry a tag? Katie Day adds breed and personality to the list: "Know your dog and their breed. Different types of dogs require different types of collars. You wouldn't put a Great Dane in the same type of collar as a Pomeranian."
Quality Signs in Stitching and Hardware
Whatever the style, quality shows in the details. Look for strong, even stitching, hardware that will not tarnish or rust, and fabric or leather that feels supple rather than stiff or scratchy. Katie suggests watching how leather bends and moves, and noticing small finishing touches such as smooth, painted edges, which signal a collar made with care. These leather dog collars that age beautifully show what well-finished leather looks like.
Ruth O'Leary recommends buying from makers who source leather from a reputable tannery, and being wary of products stamped only "genuine leather," which are often made from lower-grade material. "While made-to-order leather collars are more expensive, the quality is generally far superior to mass produced collars and will last a lot longer," she says. For pieces where craftsmanship is the whole point, these luxury dog collars from couture to craft show fine hardware and hand finishing up close.
Dog Collar Types and When to Use Each
Most dogs only ever need one simple collar, but a few specialty styles solve specific problems.
Flat Buckle and Quick-Release Collars
The everyday flat collar is the right choice for most dogs. It fastens with a belt-style buckle or a quick-release clip, holds the ID tag and has a D-ring for the leash. Belt buckles hold their size reliably and suit leather beautifully, while quick-release clips are easier to open in a hurry, which is reassuring if a collar ever snags.
Martingale Collars for Narrow Heads
Greyhounds, Whippets and other sighthounds have heads barely wider than their necks, which makes it easy for them to back out of a flat collar. A martingale adds a small second loop that tightens a limited amount when the leash pulls, closing that gap without choking. Fit it so it stays secure but never closes fully, and use it as a security collar on walks rather than a training tool.
Breakaway Collars for Play and Crate Time
A breakaway collar releases under pressure, so a dog caught on a crate wire, fence or playmate's teeth can slip free. Because it is designed to come apart, it should never be the only thing holding the leash. Some styles have a separate pair of rings for walks, and the leash needs to clip through both.
Reflective, GPS and Flea and Tick Collars
Specialty collars add a job on top of the basics. Reflective stitching or a clip-on light keeps dogs visible on early morning and evening walks, and GPS collars or tracker pockets help find a dog who slips away. Flea and tick collars slowly release an active ingredient, so ask your vet which product suits your dog and region, and read this guide to flea and tick prevention for dogs for the bigger picture.
Prong, Choke and Shock Collars to Avoid
Prong collars, choke chains and electronic shock collars work by causing discomfort or pain. Veterinary behaviorists advise against them, because aversive tools can increase fear and reactivity and may injure the delicate structures of the neck. Gentle, reward-based training works beautifully without any of them.
Dog Collar Size, Width and Fit
Measuring the Neck and the Two-Finger Rule
Wrap a soft measuring tape around the middle of your dog's neck, where the collar will sit, and choose a size that puts that measurement on one of the middle holes or adjustment points. Once fastened, two fingers should slide flat underneath. If they will not fit, the collar is too tight. If it slides over the ears with a gentle tug, it is too loose.
Long or thick coats can make a collar look tighter than it is, so part the fur and check against the skin. Recheck the fit after a grooming appointment, after any weight change and as the seasons turn.
Collar Width for Small, Medium and Large Dogs
Width should be in proportion to the dog. A narrow strip concentrates pressure on a big neck, while a wide, heavy collar can swamp a tiny one.
- Toy and small dogs: about 3/8 to 5/8 inch, with light buckles and rings
- Medium dogs: around 3/4 to 1 inch
- Large and giant breeds: 1 to 2 inches, depending on neck size and strength
Puppy Collars for Growing Necks
Puppies can outgrow a collar in a matter of weeks, so a light, adjustable fabric collar is the sensible first choice before investing in something special. Check the fit every week or so in the early months, and let your puppy get used to wearing it in short, happy sessions at home. Light buckles and rings matter too, since heavy hardware can weigh on a small neck.
Fabric vs Leather Dog Collars
The biggest decision is usually material, and both fabric and leather are lovely choices with different strengths.
Nylon, Cotton and Biothane for Wet, Muddy Days
Fabric collars are light around the neck, easy to wash and come in every color and print imaginable. For a dog who swims often, Rebecca points out that fabric is far easier to keep clean, and a waterproof biothane or coated webbing collar wipes down and dries in minutes. Neoprene padding adds comfort but can hold moisture, so dry it thoroughly after a swim. Look for smooth, sealed edges so the webbing does not fray or rub.
Leather Dog Collars for Everyday Polish
"Robust and durable, some leather collars are guaranteed for the life of the dog," says Rebecca. Leather suits hard-playing dogs and small dogs alike, softens with wear and develops a warm patina over time. Choose soft, full-grain leather for comfort, and rolled leather for long or silky coats, since its round profile is less likely to flatten or mat the fur. Padded leather suits big necks, while slim, lightweight pieces sit nicely on toy breeds.
Choosing a Collar by Breed, Coat and Walking Style
Long Coats, Sighthounds and Toy Breeds
Long-coated breeds such as Shih Tzus, Collies and doodles do best in rolled or narrow collars that glide through fur. Sighthounds often need a wider collar or a martingale for their slim heads and long necks. Toy breeds and flat-faced dogs such as Pugs and French Bulldogs have delicate throats, so a light collar for ID and a harness for the leash is the kindest combination.
Collar or Harness for a Dog Who Pulls
A collar is perfect for carrying an ID tag and clipping a leash onto a calm walker. For a dog who pulls, every lunge puts pressure on the neck and throat, so a well-fitted harness is the safer place for the leash while the collar carries the tag. This dog harness buying guide explains how to choose and fit one.
A harness manages pulling, but patient training is what changes it. These tips to stop leash pulling make walks calmer for both of you.
Adventure Dogs, Swimmers and Hikers
Dogs who spend weekends at the beach, river or trail need a collar that can take water, sand and burrs. Choose waterproof or quick-drying materials with stainless steel hardware, and rinse the collar in fresh water after salt or chlorine. Add reflective details for early starts, and pack the rest of the kit with these tips for hiking with dogs.
Dog Collar Care and Cleaning
A clean collar is kinder to the skin underneath, since dirt and trapped moisture can lead to rubbing, odor and irritation.
Washing a Fabric Collar
Rebecca's top tip is simple: check that a fabric collar is machine washable before you buy it. Pop it into a laundry or lingerie bag to protect it in the wash, then let it air dry. Wash fabric collars every few months, or whenever your dog has a bath, and rinse in cold water after a day at the beach or river to lift out sand and salt.
Cleaning and Conditioning a Leather Collar
"A quality leather collar, if well cared for, should last your dog's lifetime," says Ruth. Keep leather out of water where possible, especially salt water and chlorinated pools, which strip its natural oils. If it does get wet, rinse it in fresh water and let it air dry away from direct sun, then treat it with a leather conditioner once fully dry. Mud wipes away with a damp cloth, and if a long soak has left the leather stiff, Ruth suggests neatsfoot oil to bring back its suppleness.
When to Replace a Dog Collar
Wear Signs on Leather, Webbing and Buckles
Check the collar each time you bathe or brush your dog. Retire it when leather cracks, webbing frays, stitching loosens, buckle holes stretch or hardware rusts or bends. "If you see the leather starting to crack it's time to buy a new collar. Don't risk your dog's safety by waiting for it to break," says Ruth.
Fabric collars can stay in use for as long as they hold up, and there is no rule against a little refresh for the fun of it. Katie likes to change her own dog's collar and leash at least once a year, treating them much like a favorite pair of shoes or a well-loved handbag.
Keeping ID Tags and Microchip Details Current
A collar's most important job is helping a lost dog find the way home. Engrave the tag with a phone number that is easy to read, replace it when the lettering wears smooth, and keep microchip registration details up to date, since collars can come off. These pet ID tags and dog collar charms make that job a little prettier.
With the right type, a careful fit and a simple care routine, a good collar becomes a quiet, everyday part of every walk together. VCA Animal Hospitals offers a helpful veterinary overview of collar and harness options for dogs, including the risks behind each style and why dogs should be supervised while wearing them.
Related Reading
Share a thought, ask a question, or tell us about your own dog. We read every comment.
I buy Lupine collars and leashes. My dog is a chewer and they replace if the item is damaged by the dog.
I found a beautiful collar with great quality on easy. There is a rainbow of colors and customizable clasp for your dogs name and your contact info. The shipping is a little slower due to customization but it is definitely worth the wait.
Forgot to include the link…
https://www.etsy.com/transaction/156251542?ref=fb2_tnx_title