10 Best Handmade Plush Dogs

Ever look at your dog and wish you could freeze that cuteness forever? Or maybe you just need a version of your pooch that doesn’t bark at the mailman? Oh, we hear you! Whether you’re a proud dog mum looking for a sentimental keepsake or hunting for a playmate for the kids, a handmade plush dog is the ultimate tribute to our four-legged besties. But before we dive into the list of our absolute favorites, let’s chat about how to find ‘The One’ that’s safe, snuggly, and totally perfect. Then, get ready to meet 10 of the best handmade plush dogs that are sure to melt your heart!

1. Bubble Craft Designs

2. Natural Decor For Home

3. Crochet By Cass

4. MaxiMila Boutique

5. Luo Pan Soul

6. Woolish Duck Crochets

7. Joybly Craft

8. Johnnys Shop Australia

9. Zilly Stitches

10. Curious Cutes

11. Awe Struck Crochet

12. Loopy Couture

13. BiBi Green Home

14. Lili and Molly Co

15. Terrier Head Keyring by Edwyn UK

How to Choose the Best Handmade Plush Dog

Picking a new plushie partner is exciting, but let’s be real. Not all toys are created equal. We want to make sure your new fuzzy friend is safe, durable, and ready for all the love (and roughhousing) it’s going to get. Here is what you need to look out for.

1. Consider the Age Group

First things first: safety! Just like we puppy-proof our homes, we need to make sure these plushies are safe for the little humans in our lives. Since safety needs change as kids grow, let’s break down the essentials by age group.

• Ages 0 to 3: Our tiniest humans love to explore with their mouths (sound familiar, puppy parents?). For this age, steer clear of small removable parts like plastic eyes or buttons. They are major choking hazards. Stitched eyes are the way to go! Also, give a hard pass to long ribbons or strings to avoid strangulation risks. And of course, stick to fabrics free from nasty paints or prints that could irritate sensitive skin.
• Ages 3 to 6: Kids in this stage are soaking up knowledge like a sponge. Realistic toys are great here because they help little ones identify different animals. A plush that actually looks like a dog helps them learn! You might even grab a set, like a mama dog and her puppy, to teach family awareness. Toys with removable outfits? Yes, please! It helps them learn how to dress and care for things.
• Ages 6 and Up: Older kiddos can handle something a bit more complex. They’ll likely love a plush dog that comes with its own accessories. It’s also a great age to encourage some DIY skills. Maybe they can even learn to sew a little bandana for their new best friend!

2. Check the Materials

Let’s talk texture! The fabric defines the snuggle factor, so you want to get it right. To make sure you’re picking a winner, we need to look at both the quality of the fabric and the type of stuffing used inside.

• Wool vs. Chemical Fiber: Pure wool is luxe but can be tasty for moths (yikes!). Most toys use chemical fibers, which are usually more durable. Do a quick quality check: give the fabric a pinch. It should bounce right back and not shed in your hand. If it leaves messy stripes or loses fur, it’s a no-go.
• The Filling Matters: It’s what’s on the inside that counts, right? High-quality filling is the secret to a huggable toy. We love PP vacuum cotton. It’s hollow and elastic, meaning it bounces back fast after a big squeeze.

Avoid cheap fillers like foam or sponge that feel hard or lumpy. And definitely watch out for low-quality waste materials that can be dirty or harmful. Always do the “squeeze test”—a good plush should feel soft, consistent, and ready for a cuddle.

3. Inspect the Sewing and Workmanship

A well-made custom plush dog needs to be tough enough to survive life in a busy home. To ensure your new pal is sturdy enough for endless playdates, pay close attention to these construction details.

• The Seam Test: Take a close look at those seams. The stitching should be neat, even, and free of loose ends. Give the toy’s arm or leg a gentle tug (not too hard!). The seams should hold tight. If they separate, the stuffing could pop out, and nobody wants that mess (or safety hazard).
• Symmetry and Details: Great workmanship is all in the details. Are the eyes even? Are the ears symmetrical? A toy that looks balanced usually means the maker cared about quality inside and out. If it looks a bit wonky on the outside, the insides might be questionable, too.

4. Evaluate Safety and Durability

We want these toys to last forever, so durability is key! To ensure your chosen pup stands the test of time while keeping everyone safe, here are the main things to check.

• Choking Hazards: Watch out for accessories! While a cute collar is fun, small removable parts are a danger zone for toddlers. If you’re buying for a baby, skip the removable clothes and stick to one solid piece.
• Durability: Let’s face it, a loved toy goes through a lot. Higher quality toys have a higher stitch count, keeping all those limbs securely attached. Strong seams mean the stuffing stays where it belongs: inside the dog!

5. Consider the Toy’s Personality

We love a toy with a bit of attitude! The right personality can spark so much joy and it usually shines through in these unique details.

• Facial Expressions: Does it have a bright, happy grin? Or maybe a calm, soothing face? Kids (and adults!) often look to their plushies for comfort, so a sweet, reassuring expression is a winner.
• Design Elements: From body posture to patterns, these details add character. Neutral colours can be super calming, while bright, funky colours bring the energy! Accessories and outfits are the cherry on top that gives the toy its unique vibe.

6. Support the Child’s Interests

One of the best ways to pick a winner is to think about what makes your kiddo tick. Focusing on their specific favorites and collection style ensures the new toy becomes an instant hit.

• Favorites: What animals are they obsessed with? Do they have a favorite colour? If they are dog-crazy, maybe finding a plush that matches their favorite breed is the way to their heart.
• Variety: Does your little one love collecting? Some kids want a whole pack of similar pups, while others want a zoo of variety. If they already have a classic teddy, a unique handmade plush dog could be the perfect new addition to the squad.

Personalization and Purpose

Finally, ask yourself: what’s this plushie for?

• For Comfort: Need a stress-buster? Prioritize the softest, stroke-able fabrics like fleece or faux fur.
• For Memories: Creating a tribute to a past pet? Look for artists who can nail those realistic details, custom markings, and spot-on colors are everything here.
• For Play: If this dog is going on adventures, go for tough fabrics like canvas or sturdy cotton that can handle a bit of dirt and love.

Fluffy Editorial

Fluffy Editorial is our in-house team of writers and dog nerds. We research every topic carefully, talk to professionals when needed, and focus on sharing honest advice we’d follow with our own dogs.

You do not have any posts.